This mascara is the best I have ever bought it does exactly what it says no smudge stay on all day fantastic won’t buy anything else ever 

It doesn’t smudge but doesn’t actually work as a mascara either 

I've been using clinique mascara for years but think they've changed the formula have found it smudging under my eyes really badly. I detest switching products but took a gamble on this and so glad I have, its amazing! Builds nicely on the lashes and stays put all day long. No panda eyes, no flaking, still thick lovely lashes at bedtime. I love it.

This mascara has a great brush which easy to use & makes my eye lashes look natural. There is no smudges which is brilliant as I use eye drops. I would recommend this product if you have a problem with panda eyes ! 

I was looking for a no smudge mascara as I frequently get black smudges under my eye from mascara even though I set my under eye with a baking powder. This mascara is good! It’s easy to apply, buildable and a black mascara that darkens the lashes for a heavier look. It doesn’t crumble or flake and it’s all in all a good mascara. Unfortunately I do still get a little smudging under the eye but the amount is much less compared to a normal mascara. The bottle is quite small but a little goes a long way. I would purchase again for a daytime mascara.

This mascara is wow, builds up brilliantly but is kind to eyes but does not smudge all day and will remove easily 

I recently was bought this as a gift and have just bought it again myself. The number of compliments after using it has been unreal - someone even thought I had false eyelashes on! It doesn't smudge and lasts all day.

This is a good product. It certainly is waterproof meaning you need to get an oil-based eye makeup remover to take it off. Whilst the build on this mascara is great (as is the brush, I don't normally like a thick brush) the application is really nice. I bought this specifically for a festival themed hen weekend so I wouldn't have to worry about checking my panda eyes. However much to my dismay I found that the mascara does in-fact smudge / run. Which is a real shame as I bought this product due to to the reviews I find most mascaras do run and leave a big grey / black smudge under my eyes and this did exactly that. Once this mascara smudged I couldn't do the quick "wipe off". Really frustrating as I was really excited by this purchase.

I really love this mascara. It builds well without get clumpy and stays put. However it is quite difficult to get off. Even with a waterproof eye make up remover and cleansing oil. The tube also dries out quite quickly (perhaps because it's waterproof) - can barely get two months out of it before need to replace. Unfortunately it's a bit too costly to be ordering that often .

This mascara is magical! I have the oiliest eye area and have tried so many different mascaras over the years and they have all smudged- even the waterproof ones! This one stays put throughout the whole day with no signs of smudging or straying. It also delivers on length and volume. I have repurchased this several times now. Highly recommend!