benefit They’re Real Magnet Extreme Lengthening and Powerful Lifting Mascara - Supercharged Black 9g

Customer Reviews

benefit They’re Real Magnet Extreme Lengthening and Powerful Lifting Mascara - Supercharged Black 9g Customer Reviews

GBP 24.5

£24.50

benefit They’re Real Magnet Extreme Lengthening and Powerful Lifting Mascara - Supercharged Black 9g
Overall Rating : 4.34 / 5 (146 Reviews)
  • 98 5 star reviews
  • 22 4 star reviews
  • 10 3 star reviews
  • 9 2 star reviews
  • 7 1 star reviews
4.34 / 5 (146 Reviews)
  • 98 5 star reviews
  • 22 4 star reviews
  • 10 3 star reviews
  • 9 2 star reviews
  • 7 1 star reviews

Where reviews refer to foods or cosmetic products, results may vary from person to person. Customer reviews are independent and do not represent the views of The Hut Group.

Powders under the eye!

2

I am really disappointed Benefit! This is not a cheap mascara but performs worse than others half its price! Within a few hours this powders under the eyes, and continues doing so. It's a shame as it looks gorgeous when freshly applied. Won't buy again.

Did you find this review helpful?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Shockingly Terrible…

1

This is the worst mascara I’ve ever owned. I look like the living dead after an hour. I’ve never had a mascara that has run so much. The ironically named “Magnet” can’t seem to hold on for love nor (a lot) of money. Steer clear!  

Did you find this review helpful?

Yes (1) No (0)
Report this review

Long luscious lashes

5

I love this mascara , it makes my eyelashes so long without being clumpy ! Really impressed ! A convert ! 

Did you find this review helpful?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Smudge’s

2

The mascara looks great for around 10 mins then ends up printed all over the top and bottom of my eyes. I do seem to be quite prone to this happening so might not happen to everyone.  The best ever one for not smudging I have found is the benefit lash tint primer which you can build up. Also the benefit bad gal mascara was a lot better than this for not smudging. 

Did you find this review helpful?

Yes (2) No (0)
Report this review

Avoid

2

I’ve been using the ‘They’re real’ mascara for years and love it. So thought I’d try out this new one but it constantly smudges after wearing it for anymore than an hour, is gloopy and doesn’t lengthen as long as ‘They’re real’, I’d stick to that and save some money as I’ve just chucked this.

Did you find this review helpful?

Yes (1) No (0)
Report this review

Not the best of the mascaras!

2

I’ve been using the ‘They’re real’ mascara for years and love it. So thought I’d try out this new one but it constantly smudges after wearing it for anymore than an hour. I thought it could be down to me, but I tested it with my original ‘they’re real’ mascara on one eye and this one on the other and the difference was clear. This one just doesn’t last as long and is definitely not smudge proof! Would swap it out if I could! 

Did you find this review helpful?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Terrible - smudges

1

I've used Benefit's other mascara's inc. They're Real & Bang and thought i'd try this. I didn't rate this at all. This smudge all down my face and i constantly look like a panda in hours of using it. Unfortunately it ended up straight in the bin - a total wasted of money.

Did you find this review helpful?

Yes (1) No (0)
Report this review

Meh

3

I think it’s a bit bland to be honest. I don’t love it, I don’t hate it. It’s fine for chucking on if you just want a bit of a face but aren’t doing anything special.  I won’t be buying it again once it’s gone. 

Did you find this review helpful?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Worth Trying

5

I like this mascara. Have been using an eyelash serum and have been paying more attention to how I apply mascara and the effect it has. Pleased with two coats of product resulting in even, longer looking lashes

Did you find this review helpful?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Not up to scratch

2

I found that this mascara isn’t very wet and doesn’t lengthen my lashes as expected. I find the original benefit they’re real better at lengthening lashes so will buy this one 

Did you find this review helpful?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

benefit They’re Real Magnet Extreme Lengthening and Powerful Lifting Mascara - Supercharged Black 9g Customer Reviews

GBP 24.5

£24.50

benefit They’re Real Magnet Extreme Lengthening and Powerful Lifting Mascara - Supercharged Black 9g

Quantity

( 0 item is in your basket items are in your basket )

Other customers bought: