really hard to get off but not in a good way scrubbing at eye using eye makeup remover and hardly coming off.  The applicators are thick and hard to get thin lines  the colour is good and matt as stated but all in all a awful product 

This is the best waterproof eyeliner I have come across in many years of hunting. It really does the job for my watery eyes. It is thick and so is the brush, but by pressing the wand against the side when removing you can flatten it to get a good sharp point. Easy to remove with Almay eye make-up remover pads - as good as the late-lamented Boots eye make-up remover pads, now sadly discontinued and much missed.

This is a brilliant eyeliner. It doesn't budge all day, even on my oily eyelids. The tube lasts for a good 3 months using it every day. The only drawback is the brush - it's quite long, thin and soft, making it tricky to create a sharp point to your wing

I was laughing when people said it was really hard to remove this eyeliner, but they were right! I don’t know how “healthy” it’s gonna be on my eyes, when my amazing makeup removal can’t remove it, and it takes SCRUBBING to get it off. Quality and colour is great, but this is a big cons for me.

This is THE eyeliner for anyone who is looking for a product that does not budge. If you have oily skin this eyeliner is ideal for you, trust me. best use oil-based make up remover or a melt-away cleansing balm

Very difficult to take off with normal makeup remover. I have had to buy coconut oil which takes it off but with effort. The actual look of it is great but I'm looking to buy another NYX liner which is easier to remove.

I have deep set, hooded eyes that get super oily, so I had low expectations for this product, but I was impressed! Easy to apply (although I would prefer a thinner tip) and stays on for 12+ hours with no fading, and no smudges. I’ve been looking for a good cruelty free eyeliner for ages and this is it!

I originally bought it in black, loved it so much I bought 5 black backups, and then purchased a brown and a black metal version too. I honestly couldn't love this more than I do. It does not budge - make sure your liner game is on point as you can't correct any mistakes during application. To remove it after wearing, I use a bi-phase makeup remover or a cleansing balm with warm water on a face cloth and patience is required!

Bring back the NYX matte. This one is so thick it's impossible to apply a small amount and neatly. It gets stuck in my eyelashes so they're clumped together and my mascara doesn't go on properly. It also doesn't help that my brush was bent on opening.