benefit They're Real Push-up Gel Eyeliner Black

I’m an avid cat wing eyeliner fan and wearer along with a benefit fan, so I really wanted to like this, but I just couldn’t get along with it. I tried all the tricks and just found it dragged and didn’t leave clean lines, along with that crumbly finish. Doesn’t budge when it’s dried though to be fair. I won’t be buying again.

I love this eyeliner and every time it runs out I re-buy. It’s always helpful that I am usually able to get some kind of discount via the look fantastic discount codes. The formula is perfectly smooth and I buy it in black. It is the blackest black and doesn’t budge all day long. Other eyeliners I have used (and I have tried many) simply do not have the intensity of this. I have read reviews saying it dries out and can be crumbly. I have experienced this in the past when too much product has shot out of the end and has not been used. It dries out by the next day. I find just one twist is enough product for both eyes. You have to get used to doing the right amount for your eyes otherwise you will end up with more product that you need and it dries out at the top. Which frustrated me the first time I purchased. However I would say it is worthwhile bearing with as it really is the best, strongest, smoothest eyeliner I have ever purchased and the staying power is 100% there! I can’t do without it in my make up bag!

I bought this Eyeliner a month ago, didnt use it every day (cause its expencive) and not even a month has passed and its already dried out. I was really hoping I found a perfect eyeliner....

Good lasting eyeliner but quite difficult to apply

For the price I expected it to stay put all day but instead it crumbles and cracked on my lids leaving an imperfect flick throughout the day. Not feeling this.

Worst product i've ever bought from benifit, or even the worst beauty product i've tried…. The colour looks good but it breaks! It breaks in every movement! Dont waste your money on this, you can find better

I really like this product its easy to apply, it hugs the lashes and is nice and black.

This liner is great for getting perfect flicks! So easy to use and last ages!

A fairly average product. Brought it because it was abit different and I liked the idea that the gel wouldn't smudge, but I find it doesn't come out how I expected, it doesn't flow across my eyes, can be abit clumpy at times. Probably won't buy again

I had read mixed reviews on this product however I still decided to try it out. First impressions were really great - good application, lasting finish, very pigmented. However, the more I used it the less manageable it became! The twister does not work well!